“Moment of Truth” edited by Jamie Stern-Weiner— Whose Truth?

Stern-Weiner, Jamie, editor. “Moment of Truth: Tackling Israel-Palestine’s Toughest Questions”, OR Books, 2018.

Whose Truth?

Amos Lassen

It has been more than a century since the Balfour Declaration and more than 50 years since the Six-Day War in 1967, and a full decade into the siege of Gaza (as this editor prefers to call it but then she also names her book “Moment of Truth”— I guess that means which side you are on since no one is neutral) and the Israel-Palestine conflict rolls on. Now pay carful attention to the construct of this next sentence: “Amidst a growing sense that the Palestinians’ long struggle for self-determination has reached a crossroads, if not an impasse, this volume takes stock, draw lessons from experience, and weigh paths forward.” (This “volume draws lessons”— from whom? When a book is one-sided the question of research and honesty is paramount. What I see as paramount here is milking a situation to make a few coins quickly.)

Here is a list of contributors to this volume so please carefully note the names and count the number of Israelis to the number of Arabs and yes, do not forget scholar Norman Finkelstein who has been run out of every school h has ever held a position with and is a self appointed Jewish anti-Semite who denies the Holocaust which his parents survived:

Musa Abuhashhash, As’ad Abukhalil, Mkhaimar Abusada, Gilbert Achcar, Ghaith al-Omari, Ghassan Andoni, Usama Antar, Nur Arafeh, Shaul Arieli, Arie Arnon, Tareq Baconi, Sam Bahour, Sari Bashi, Shlomo Ben-Ami, Suhad Bishara, Nathan J. Brown, Diana Buttu, John Dugard, Michael Dumper, Hagai El-Ad, Richard A. Falk, Norman G. Finkelstein, Neve Gordon, Ran Greenstein, Yoaz Hendel, Jamil Hilal, Khaled Hroub, Amal Jamal, Jan de Jong, Leila Khaled, Raja Khalidi, Rami G. Khouri, Lior Lehrs, Gideon Levy, Alon Liel, John J. Mearsheimer, Jessica Montell, Rami Nasrallah, Wendy Pearlman, Nicola Perugini, William B. Quandt, Mazin B. Qumsiyeh, Glen Rangwala, Glenn E. Robinson, Nadim Rouhana, Sara Roy, Bashir Saade, Robbie Sabel, Dahlia Scheindlin, Daniel Seidemann, Michael Sfard, Muhammad Shehada, Raja Shehadeh, Sammy Smooha, Mark Tessler, Nathan Thrall, Ahmed Yousef, Ido Zelkovitz.

What a fine well-balanced group. Now since the book dispenses hate so well, I’ll just quote it all:”


“Moment of Truth seeks to clarify what it would take to resolve the Israel-Palestine conflict, to assess the prospects of doing so, and to illuminate what is possible in Palestine. It assembles an unprecedented wealth of expertise—encompassing political leaders, preeminent scholars, and dedicated activists from Israel, Palestine, and abroad—in direct critical exchange on the issues at the heart of the world’s most intractable conflict. Has Israel’s settlement enterprise made a Palestinian state impossible? Can the Palestinian leadership end the occupation? Is Israel’s rule in the Palestinian territories a form of apartheid? Could the US government force Israel to withdraw? In a series of compelling, enlightening, and at times no-holds-barred debates, leading authorities tackle these and other challenges, exposing myths, challenging preconceptions, and establishing between them a more sober and informed basis for political action.”


Jamie Stern-Weiner, the editor of Moment of Truth: Tackling Israel-Palestine’s Toughest Questions, publishing next week says “Two million people have been herded into one of the most densely populated areas on the planet, denied the prerequisites for a functioning economy, pummeled with the most sophisticated military equipment on earth, and left to rot. 

Yesterday, May 14, as many as 80,000 people in Gaza marched upon the perimeter fence to protest their imprisonment. 

Their motivation was eloquently expressed by Olfat al-Kurd, a 37 year-old mother of four who works in Gaza as a human rights activist:

Israel has been holding Gaza under blockade for more than ten years. Some of the young people participating in the protests, and being wounded or even killed by soldiers, do not know what it’s like to have running water and a steady supply of electricity. They have never left Gaza and grew up in a prison. 

There is no real life in Gaza. The whole place is clinically dead. 

The younger generations are crushed by the hopelessness and death everywhere. The protests have given us all a spark of hope. They are our attempt to cry out to the world that it must wake up, that there are people here fighting for their most basic rights, which they are entitled to fulfill. We deserve to live, too.” Did I see her mention that Caza has become an incubation rook for terrorism? Did she mention how many terrorists from Gaza have killed innocent Israelis? Yet she maintains this is a balanced picture.


“The demonstrations were overwhelmingly nonviolent, as they have been since the Great Return March began some seven weeks ago. Israel responded with a massacre: 52 dead, including five children, and some 2,500 wounded. A senior Human Rights Watch official described their murder:

This is about individual snipers safely ensconced hundreds of feet, even farther, away, targeting individual protestors and executing them one at a time.”

“As the Red Cross warned that Gaza’s health system was ‘on the verge of collapse’, straining to cope with the mass influx of casualties, President Trump tweeted: ‘Big day for Israel. Congratulations!’ 

Today, May 15, will likely see Gazans in unprecedented numbers attempt en masse to break free of their cage. The danger of further slaughter looms large, demanding that supporters of justice and international law around the world take action to restrain Israel’s bloodletting and educate themselves about solutions capable of ensuring that such atrocities do not continue.”








Leave a Reply